Christ United Methodist Church    Bethel Park, Pennsylvania

Christ United
Methodist
Church

 

    


Home  |  About Us  |  Calendar  |  Church Staff  |  Contact Us  |  Directions  |  Ministries  |  SermonsWorship Services


Questions You May Have Asked
#4: Did that water really become wine?


   

A sermon given by Brian Bauknight on September 26,  2004

   

Bible Text:

 

Text: “When the servant tasted the water that had become wine, and did not know where it came from… [The] steward called the bridegroom and said to him, ‘Everyone serves the good wine first, and then the inferior wine after the guests have become drunk. But you have kept the good wine until now.’”                                                                      (John 2:9-10)

 

There’s an old story about a man who is driving drunk one night. The police stopped him. “Have you been drinking?” said the policeman. “No sir,” came the reply. “Not a drop.” 

“Then what’s that bottle on the floor beside you?” The man looked down and saw the wine bottle there. “Oh, that,” he said. “It’s just some water I drink as I drive.” 

“Let me see the bottle,” said the policeman. The man handed the policeman the bottle. The policeman sniffed it, and then said, “This is not water. This is wine.” 

Whereupon the man looked up and said, “Oh Lord, don’t tell me you’ve done it again!” 

Did Jesus really change 150 gallons of water into vintage wine? Have you ever asked yourself that question? Have you ever thought about asking it? Our modern age wants answers like that. 

There’s a story about a teetotaling mother who was trying to convince her 16-year-old daughter never to take a drink. “Never, never, never have a drink of anything with alcohol in it!” she exclaimed. “But Mother,” said the daughter, “Didn’t Jesus himself change water into wine in a story in the Bible?” With fire in her eyes, the mother shot back, “Yes, I suppose he did. But he shouldn’t have done it either!” 

Did Jesus change water into wine? The writer of the fourth Gospel chooses a somewhat unusual way to introduce the public ministry of Jesus. In Matthew and Mark, Jesus’ public ministry begins with healing miracles. In Luke, his ministry begins with a sermon preached in his hometown of Nazareth. But in John, the public ministry of Jesus begins with his presence at a wedding banquet. There he changes six large jars of water into some very good wine. 

There’s a line in the liturgy for the wedding service in the United Methodist Church that goes something like this: “Marriage is an honorable estate, which Jesus himself adorned and beautified by his presence at Cana of Galilee.” This is a direct reference to the story. 

I suggest to you this morning that the deepest meaning of this story does not lie in the details of what happened. The facts of the story are not the point for John. The meaning of this story does not depend upon the exact details.  

Let me share some background with you. We need to know some of this background in order to understand the power of the story. Weddings were festive occasions in peasant life in Palestine. Cana was definitely a peasant town. In such instances the wedding lasted about 7 days. The bride and groom never left town. There was no honeymoon. They were like a king and queen in the town for a week. They held a weeklong open house. 

There was lots of food and drink and dancing. The food went far beyond the ordinary. In most simple homes, the best people could hope for was a little bit of fish and some grain. But at the time of a wedding, the food was an all-out production. 

And wine was the drink of choice. The wine flowed freely. Wine was consumed because there wasn’t much safe water to drink. I visited the Holy Land early in my young adult life. At the time I believed that even a small sip of alcohol was somehow an evil thing to do. I visited in a home of some friends in Jerusalem. Wine was on the table. I insisted on having ice water instead. I was sick for three days. Wine was common and valued at weddings. It was the fluid intake of choice. 

You also need to know that there were plenty of similar images in Scripture. Scripture points frequently to something called the Messianic Banquet. Jesus is referred to as the Groom, and his followers are the Bride. There are many images of a great celebration feast, including some of the parables of Jesus. The Book of Revelation speaks of “the marriage supper of the Lamb.” So the image of a wedding banquet would not be at all unusual. 

To this wedding, Jesus is invited. It could be said that the preacher is the last person you want to invite to a really good party. Years ago I had an auto repairman friend who owned a shop called “The Route 30 Auto Repair” near Irwin. One afternoon I took my car up to see if it could be serviced. I parked the car and walked up to the garage. Inside I heard a lot of loud, raucous laughter. A radio was blaring loudly in the background. The owner of the store saw me coming. Suddenly he shouted, “Well, good afternoon, R-e-v-e-r-e-n-d!” 

Immediately all of the laughter and conversation came to a standstill. Someone even reached up and turned down the radio. A preacher is the last person you invite to a good party. 

We had friends in the North Hills who had a Scandinavian Christmas party. It was called a “glug” party. The center of the party was some flaming alcohol in a dish that started the festivities. I remember them telling us later they were not sure if they should have invited us or not. Preachers sometimes tend to threaten or thwart a good party. 

But Jesus was invited. He was there. And a curious thing happened—the wine began to run out after only a few days. We need to understand what that means. 

Basically it meant poor hospitality. You don’t run out of wine at weddings. It’s a social disaster. Perhaps it was because more people came than were expected. Maybe it’s because the disciples drank more than expected. 

We took our two teenage grandsons on an Alaskan cruise this past summer. I don’t think the Carnival Cruise Line will ever recover on the food loss for that week! Those boys ate 4 meals a day and made 35 trips to the pizza counter during 7 days. 

The host (or the bride and groom) in this Biblical wedding story were about to run out of wine. 

Elaine and I attended a wedding reception once where half of the guests were delayed their food for an hour. Apparently one bank of ovens in the kitchen went down and the chef didn’t know it until it was time to serve the meal. It was total embarrassment for the host family. This story gives us an indication of what that might be like. 

Mary says to Jesus, “Son, they are about to run out of wine.” Jesus sees the large jars standing against the wall. He calls over the wedding coordinator, hands him a ladle and says, “Here, try some of this.” The wedding coordinator takes a sip and a broad smile comes across his face. He runs over to the host and says, “Here, taste this wine.” The result is not only wine, but an excellent wine. 

The party takes off again in high fashion. There is a story about a preacher who was preaching one day against the evils of alcohol. He said, “I want to take all the beer in this town and toss it in the river. I want to take all the liquor in this town and throw it in the river. I want to take all the wine in this town and throw it in the river.” When they announced the closing hymn, the hymn was entitled; “Shall We Gather at the River.” 

Symbolically, the crowd at Cana probably sang, “Shall We Gather at the River.” The party resumed. No more hitches. No more glitches. A crisis had been averted. 

So this is a memorable wedding party. I remember a story about a hotel that housed a convention for both a group of salespersons and a group of clergy. They served a banquet to the two groups in the same hotel at the same time. The salespersons were to have spiked watermelon for dessert. But the waiters inadvertently served the watermelon to the clergy group instead.  

When the chef discovered what had happened, he was alarmed. He sent the headwaiter out to see if any of the watermelon could be retrieved to be served to the salespersons’ group. The headwaiter returned, shaking his head. “It’s too late,” he said. “It’s almost all gone.”  

“Well,” said the chef, “did they like it?” 

Replied the waiter, “I’m not really sure, sir. All I can tell you is that they were taking the seeds and putting them in their pockets.” 

That was a banquet to be talked about for years to come. People have some wonderful wedding stories to tell. There was a woman who owned a 7-11 store, who decided to get married. She decided they would be married in the parking lot. She carried her flowers in a “Big Gulp” cup. The reception consisted of hot dogs and slurpees at reduced prices. Or in Maine, a couple met at the town transfer station, affectionately called “The Dump.” They decided to get married there. They got married standing in the bucket loader. Townspeople donated returnable bottles for the honeymoon. The headline said, “The couple couldn’t wait to say ‘I do’ at the Dump.” 

I’m quite sure that Ruth Sanford or Mary Ann Weber, who have been our wedding hostesses here, have stories to tell as well. But this is more than a memorable wedding. This is more than a wedding story to tell to your grandchildren. This is more than a miracle story. 

What is this story about? Beyond the transformation, beyond the miracle? Let me suggest some possible answers. 

THE CENTRAL SIGNIFICANCE OF JESUS 

It may simply be about the central significance of Jesus. Prior to Jesus’ coming, the wine was only so-so. It was an average quality, a cheap burgundy. But in Jesus, the very best has come. The steward says to the host, “You have saved the very best wine for last.” 

John may be saying to us that in Jesus, life will be different. It will be noticeably better. Earlier in John the writer has said, “The law came through Moses. Grace and truth came through Jesus.” The meaning for this story may be as simple as that. 

AN ADDITIONAL POSSIBILITY 

But there is an additional real possibility. Notice how the story begins. Notice the first words: “Now on the third day there was a wedding in Cana of Galilee.” Do you think those are casual words? Do you think they are accidental? Maybe even trivial? I don’t think so. No word is casual in John’s gospel. Each is chosen with care. 

What else happened on the third day in the New Testament story? Easter! Is this not a story about the Easter people? The symbolism here may be very clear. Life with the risen Jesus is like a really good wedding party. There are lots of people. There’s lots of singing and dancing. There’s good food and good wine. It may be reminiscent of an Easter hymn that we sing during the Easter season. 

Easter people, raise your voices,

Sounds of heaven in earth should ring.

Christ has brought us heavenly choices;

Heavenly music, let it ring.

Alleluia! Alleluia! Easter people, let us sing!                      (UM Hymnal 304) 

SO THE EASTER LIFE IS LIKE A GREAT PARTY 

John is telling us that the Easter life is like a great party. John is reminding us that life after Easter is a grand and glorious banquet. The food is plentiful and the wine never runs out. Or again, the Easter wine is really good, and there is plenty of it. John is not an advocate for heavy use of wine here. I don’t want to see everybody down at the now-open-on-Sunday state liquor store after the service is over today! But this is not a “temperance” story. Such thoughts never occurred to first century writers. 

Abundant wine is a symbol for real joy. Jesus brings joy to life in you. There is more than enough. 150 to 180 gallons of wine is a lot of wine. This is more than just a friendly bottle brought by a guest to thank the host for inviting him. I am reminded of the text in a Psalm that says, “You have put more joy in my heart than others have when the wine and grain abound.” 

WE ARE INVITED TO LIVE JOY 

John invites us to live in that kind of joy. Remember the movie called “City Slickers” (starring Billy Crystal) in 1991? Billy Crystal plays a man who is floundering for purpose in his life. He’s going through a kind of mid-life crisis. The joy of life seems elusive. He and a friend try a variety of activities to try to stimulate their lives again. Finally they go off to a dude ranch. It will become a new adventure. The final words of his wife to the Billy Crystal character are these: “Go. Go and find your smile.” 

Jesus came to make you and me smile—deep down, and forever. Even in the midst of mind-numbing tragedy, even in the midst of an endless barrage of hurricanes and flooding, even in the midst of sickness or human discomfort, we can live with a deep, sturdy joy. St. Teresa of Avila writes about Christians being “happy-hearted people.” The Christian life is a great banquet of happy-hearted people. 

ONE MORE POSSIBILITY 

There is one more possibility in this story. If Jesus can change water into wine, he can change you and me as well. This is a story about transformation. 

Someone once wrote, “I have seen the miracle of water changed to wine. But I have seen beer changed into furniture. I have seen anger changed into gentleness, sourness into sweetness, bitterness into peace.” The wedding in Cana is a metaphor for new, transformational beginnings. 

John has the richest symbolic language in the New Testament. This story is majestic in its meaning. It’s the story of how central Jesus is to us. It’s the story of the Easter life of faith. It’s the story of a new birth of joy in Jesus. It’s the story of personal transformational possibilities. 

I hope you will never read this story again in the same way: “And on the third day, there was a wedding in Cana of Galilee, and Jesus was there.”

  

   
   

44 Highland Road  |  Bethel Park, Pennsylvania  15102  |  Phone 412-835-6621

Copyright © 2000-2002 CUMC - February 25, 2005